Goodwill Hunting - A Little More News of the A303 Feasibility Study

As we said a couple of posts ago, there seems to have been very little activity over the summer regarding the A303/A30/A358 corridor feasibility study, which, given the Parliamentary recess, summer holidays and, for once, a half-way reasonable summer, isn’t all that surprising.  That isn’t to say nothing has been going on.  It seems the study is a bit like a swan on water – not much going on above the surface, but some furious (?) paddling going on below.

Robert Goodwill MP

We are a bit disappointed though.  Back at the start of the year, we (STAG) wrote to the Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Transport, Robert Goodwill MP, expressing our interest, as a local pressure group in the Stonehenge area, in getting involved in all stages of the study.  Back in January, Goodwill’s Assistant Private Secretary came back with the following response:

A Minion, but maybe not the correct DfT Minion?

“…We are also conducting national events to gather views from environmental organisations and other motoring and business groups.

We understand your interest in the study and rest assured, we plan to engage more widely with local groups in the next few weeks. I will ensure that you are kept informed”.

An apparent show of goodwill by Goodwill and his trusty minion.   Unfortunately, these were hollow words and there has been no engagement or even contact as promised.

We do get a few snippets from the meetings that are going ahead though.  The latest was held in Taunton just over a week ago. John Glen MP (Con – Salisbury) was the only MP there at the start of the meeting.  Wiltshire Council were represented by Cllr Fleur De Rhe-Philippe and Mr Parvis Khansari.  David Heath MP (Lib-Dem - Somerton and Frome) represented Somerset interests.

John Glen MP

John Glen pressed home the well-considered view that they realised that any solution without a bypass for Winterbourne Stoke, and a deliverable solution at Stonehenge, was not going to make the A303 a reliable strategic route to SW.

David Heath MP

 David Heath seems to have suggested that the DfT should press ahead with improving other bits of the corridor, even if a solution at Stonehenge is too expensive.  To us that smacks of selfish-self-interest and is profoundly illogical; spending lots of public money to improve roads that the majority of users at peak periods will still have to queue to join and to leave.  A case of blinkered vision!  Let’s hope he is taken to task by Salisbury Lib-Dems when he visits the city this week.

All in all, it seems that the officials at DfT don’t want too much detailed information out in the public domain until they have got all the costings sorted out.  It is clear that they are considering more than one potential solution and options for solutions that both involve and don’t involve tunnels of varying lengths, along various routes.   Superficially, at least, it seems they have kept open minds and haven’t yet been forced to accept historic solutions.

In typical government fashion, when some detail does emerge, we might expect to see costings for several different options with a “Do Nothing” option (there are significant costs attached to doing nothing in terms of lost tourist and business) and a “preferred” option or two.  Time will tell.

The good news is that English Heritage and the National Trust seem to be being a little more open-minded than they have been in the past.  On the down-side, the Stonehenge Alliance seem to be less willing to compromise.   Sadly, that is what it will need to come down to, negotiation and compromise by all parties.  

John Hayes MP

 In a further development on Monday this week, John Glen MP took the opportunity to press his case for the A303 improvement with the new roads minister the Rt Hon John Hayes MP (Con - South Holland and The Deepings).  Mr Glen particularly stressed the need to produce a solution for the whole of the A303 corridor and that to improve parts of the A303 without solving the Stonehenge conundrum would be a failure .

English Heritage Mess Up on the A344 - Yet Again

Last month we heard from Wiltshire Council, definitively they claim, that the A344 is still the A344 and a highway.  As "A" roads have a legal definition in the UK and that involves joining population centres, carrying motorised traffic, etc, it is patently absurd to continue to list the A344 as an "A" road.  Consequently, this is being taken up with the Secretary of State for resolution.

Meanwhile, on the A344, English Heritage continue to mess up.  As a planning condition for the new visitor's centre, they were obliged to install Kent Carriage Gaps to allow all non-motorised traffic, not banned by the permanent Traffic Regulation Order, to use the A344, unhindered, 24/7.  Like many of the planning conditions imposed on English heritage (around 23 of them) many were supposed to be put in place before the visitor's centre was opened to the public,; the management plan seems to suggest sometinme between October and December 2013.  Yet again, this was a major fail by English Heritage.  Wiltshire Council Planning Department seem to have done little to police these consents, which makes you wonder what they spend their time doing!

Now for those of you who don't know, a Kent Carriage Gap is one of the ways of enforcing a TRO of the sort imposed on the A344.  This is how they should be designed:

Two sizes of post to allow carriages of different sizes to pass along the carriageway.  The separation of the posts and their height is also defined.

The point of these gaps is to allow unhindered access along the carriageway - the operative word here being along.  This is how they should be constructed.

Have English Heritage achieved this?  No, of course not.  Almost 9 months late, this is all they have been able to manage.

Between the new roundabout at Airman's Cross and the entrance to the visitor's centre carpark you have this attempt, photographed by Wiltshire Councillor and Chairman of Winterbourne Stoke Parish Council Ian West and friends,  it certainly doesn't seem fit for purpose, doesn't meet the design of Kent Carriage Gap for which planning consent was given, and wouldn't appear to be able to be used as intended by all the types of carriage it is meant to permit. 

Further along, we come to an even more egregious mess which we photographed last week in the run-up to the presidential visit!

Well, on the plus side, EH have lowered the kerb.  But that is the only positive thing that can be said about it.  The Gap is again to one side of the A344, not across it and there is no clear exit from it back onto the A344.  It's worse than that, bearing in mind that the path running from left to right comes down from the coach park and is the main access for visitors being brought in from that direction.  Now, given these pedestrians are about to cross an open highway, the A344, in very large numbers, you'd think English Heritage would have had the common sense to do a number of things.  First, leading pedestrians onto and across a highway, without warning them they are crossing one is a fairly stupid thing to do; particularly given that many of them are foreign visitors. 

Second, not warning those using the highway that there may be pedestrians about is also pretty lame, so you'd think there might be proper signage on the path and the road, "Look both ways" signs on the footpath, etc, etc, but no such luck.  All in all, when we have our first visitor mown down by a horse rider, horse and carriage or even a cyclist, the negligence on English Heritage's part will be clear.

In writing this, we realise we never actually measured the height and separation of the posts that are there, so we might have to pop up and measure them to be sure.

Ian West and friends also looked at the state of the permissive byway at the other end of the old A344, beyond Byway 12 and towards Stonehenge Bottom.  English Heritage, keen to foster the World Heritage Site's policy of encouraging visits by cyclists have signposted the route:

You've got to admire the lengths they have gone to over the last 9 months to do this!  Of course, if you take the trouble to go down that way,  avoiding the inevitable traffic jam at byway 12...

...you can get a really good view of Stonehenge, without having to pay the extortionate entry charge.  Follow this up with a visit to the museums in Amesbury, Salisbury or Devizes and you will see the best of Wiltshire's archaeology - you don't even need a local resident's pass.

All we can say is that it is a good job President Obama didn't arrive by bike and that Raffles family of Amesbury decided to walk up to Stonehenge from the east, rather than go by car, or else the six of them would never have met and English Heritage couldn't have benefited, however undeservedly, from the global human interest story that broke following the president's visit. 

President Barack Obama Contributes to A303 Road Chaos

As I write, it seems that President Barack Obama is gracing Wiltshire with his presence.  Unfortunately, the President of the US and leader of the free world as he may well be, has been contributing to traffic chaos on the A303 for most of the afternoon.

Having flown in to Boscombe Down earlier, his motorcade went north across the blocked A303, up to Larkhill and then approached the Stonehenge visitor's centre from the Bustard crossroads.  So, he's officially a rat runner and (with tongue firmly in cheek) I expect that STAG will be making representations to the White House about such bad behaviour.

We wonder if he had pre-booked his visit to Stonehenge, as he's certainly not a local resident and whether he paid the usual extortionate entrance charge.  We think perhaps not. 

Of course, the serious point is that the A303 isn't fit for your average motorist, let alone for President Obama.

UPDATE

Although he wasn't allowed to drive along the A303,  President Obama appears to have flown alongside it as he left Boscombe Down this evening, with what appeared to be Marine One flying directly over Winterbourne Stoke and the rest of his entourage flying slightly to the south of the village.

 Most notable were the lead group of 3 Bell-Boeing V22 Osprey's (aka "The Widowmaker").  These were possibly from the 7th Special Operations Squadron, 352d Special Operations Group from RAF Mildenhall.  So from causing jams on the A303, the president managed to trump that by causing a veritable traffic jam above it.  Click to enlarge and see just how many helicopters were involved!

Pedestrian Critical After Being Hit By Car Near Stonehenge

 We've been fairly quiet over the summer, monitoring the now near daily chaos on the A303.  We now return, but in the saddest way possible, to report a serious road traffic accident.

 We don't yet know all the circumstances, but at around 8:45pm of Friday evening, a 37 year old man from the Gwent area of Wales was struck by a west-bound Mercedes 300 driven by a 28 year old London man on the stretch of the A303 between Stonehenge and here in Winterbourne Stoke.  The road was closed until after midnight.

The pedestrian is reported this lunchtime as being in critical condition with serious head injuries.

Anyone who saw the accident is asked to call Wiltshire Police on 101 or Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111.

UPDATE:

Sadly, the individual concerned, Patrick Sturtivant, did not survive.  Our thoughts and condolences go out to his family.

The more we hear about this incident, the more predictable it all was.  In fact, all the recent changes to the road system around Stonehenge, and access to the proximity of the stones, made it all but inevitable.

In the past, westbound traffic, wanting to spend a few minutes getting a "trophy" shot of Stonehenge, possibly the most photographed man-made object in the world, used to pull off onto the A344, a route where the majority of the traffic used the road regularly and where the drivers where used to tourists spilling into the road, thumbs up bums, brains in neutral, thoughts fixed only on taking a happy snap.  As a consequence, and quite unwittingly,  road safety was policed by local drivers.  Of course, the closure of the A344 put paid to that.

The second factor that might have contributed to this accident, again fairly predictably, was the "no right turn" signage on the A303 - attempting to prevent traffic turning on to Byway 12.  This was done on the spurious pretext of road safety.  Why spurious?  Well, unlike many of the small turnings off the A303 to the west of Amesbury, the entrance to Byway 12 is visible from a good half mile in either direction.  We suspect the real reason behind the signage is twofold.  First, a legitimate attempt to stop the traffic on the A303 slowing and causing congestion and second, a sop to English Heritage's long-held desire to close Byway 12, completely, to force all visitors to enter the World Heritage Site at Airman's Cross.  Of course, trying to improve traffic flow by banning right turns off the A303 was completely counter productive.  The travelling public did the blindingly obvious - slow, or even stop on the A303 to take that all important photo.

On this occasion, it seems that Mr Sturtivant, travelling west at dusk last Friday, pulled off the A303 at Byway 11, to the east of Byway 12.  Not much local traffic here, just long distance travellers, frustrated by earlier delays, simply wanting to get to the West Country for the weekend.   No doubt there was a glimpse to the right for a quick look at the stones by the Mercedes driver and then he was at Byway 12...

Four Thousand Holes in Blackburn Lancashire, Four Hundred Cameras Around Shrewton, Wiltshire

I do have to apologise to the memory of the late and great John Lennon for abusing the lyrics of "A Day in the Life" but I simply couldn't resist drawing the analogy.

Yesterday, the Salisbury Journal published a very interesting article on the A303 entitled simply: "A303 traffic survey to be carried out"

Basically, the story explains that Atkins, the traffic management consultancy will be placing number plate recognition cameras along the A303 and on surrounding roads as part of a scheme to track vehicle movements on the traffic-choked highway.The Journal article claims that there will be hundreds of these cameras on the surrounding roads, but we suspect that this might be something of an exaggeration and that perhaps 10-20 NPR cameras might be closer to the mark.

Winterbourne Stoke resident, Chairman of the parish council and Wiltshire councillor Ian West observed: "Residents of Shrewton believe the speed and volume of traffic in Shrewton has been made worse by the closure of the A344.

One of the main concerns expressed by local residents is the speed and volume of traffic, it is quoted as one of the main safety factors which people see as a barrier to travelling around their communities on foot or by bicycle or to letting children travel independently. This has very much affected the quality of life in Shrewton.

We very much look forward to the results of the Atkins survey because the increase in traffic is becoming unbearable in Shrewton and the surrounding villages both sides of the A303.” 

Of course, it isn't just Shrewton or indeed the residents here in Winterbourne Stoke who are suffering as a result of the A344 closure.  We (WiSBAng) and the Stonhenge Traffic Action Group (STAG), regularly hear of problems being caused as far afield as Berwick St James, Larkhill, Durrington, Bulford and Amesbury.

Although we wholeheartedly welcome this new initiative and data-gathering exercise, we feel duty-bound to point out something that some might think verges on negligence on the part of Wiltshire Council.  Over the last two decades and more, every bit of traffic modelling undertaken on the A303 corridor, some of it commissioned by Wiltshire Council, predicted that there would be traffic chaos in the surrounding villages if the A344 were to be closed BEFORE the A303 was upgraded.  For years, Wiltshire Council resisted the closure of the A344 on those grounds, then in 2010/2011 they did an about face and sided with English Heritage in pushing for the closure.

Surprise, surprise.  The A344 was closed and all the traffic models were proved correct. 

Now any competent authority would have undertaken a survey such as that being carried out by Atkins between Monday, August 4th and Sunday, August 10th prior to closing the A344, then do the same again after the closure to ensure the changes had had no adverse effects and to be able to quantify the changes with hard data.  That would have been far too sensible and of course it might have run the risk of exposing, in irrefutable terms, that a mistake had been made in closing the A344 prematurely.  That would never do, would it?

As it is, when Atkins report their findings we will know how bad the situation on all these local roads is, but in the absence of knowing what they were like in quantitative terms before the A344 closure, it is impossible to say how much worse they have become.  We can make some estimates based on earlier surveys, but on fewer roads, using somewhat different methodologies; that's far from ideal.

Was That the TDF Peloton Arriving in Winterbourne Stoke?

Since the summer solstice there has been precious little to report on the A303.  Stories of any substance have been hard to find and we had resorted to searching the internet for anything interesting.  We wondered just how many stories on the A303 had been initiated by Wiltshire Council since the start of the year, sitting in all their pontificatorial splendour in Trowbridge?  Given that the A303 is the major east-west trunk road in the south of the county, given its importance to the local economy and especially given the fact HMG are currently looking at the feasibility of improving the A303 through the county, you might expect some fairly regular stories to emerge.  Stories saying just how important this work was and how the county council was 100% behind it.  You might expect such stories but you would be gravely disappointed, there's not been a single one, nada, nothing, bugger-all.  Either Wiltshire Council, as some claim, are overly focussed on the north of the county, or they are determined to kowtow to central government when it comes to the A303.  There was a time when Wiltshire Council and Wiltshire councillors had a bit of backbone.  For whatever reason, they seem to be becoming invertebrates.

On Monday evening, the Winterbourne Stoke Parish Council held its regular meeting.  Lots of things on the agenda and several of them related to the A303 and surrounding roads.  As ever, the meeting was good humoured and purposeful and at the end of it, all the Parish Councillors were going wander down through the village to look at the playpark.

As we came to cross the A303, back into the village we saw a sight that made our blood run cold.  There was a convoy of around 30 to 40 cyclists riding down the A303 from the direction of Longbarrow Roundabout and Stonehenge, all in high-visibility jackets and most riding line astern. It looked like the Tour de France peloton had taken a wrong turn and finished up in Wiltshire. Way too many yellow jerseys to work out which one was Vincenzo Nibali winning yet another mountain stage!  As they got closer, there was a collective holding of breath as several vans passed them.  Regular users of the A303 are only to well aware that the road is barely wide enough to allow vehicles to pass in opposite directions.  It's way too narrow to allow overtaking.  Thankfully, at 9:15pm on a Monday evening, traffic is light and the riders survived long-enough for some of them to pull off the road at the end of Church Street.

We crossed the road to see if we could help them as it was clear that they were lost.  We couldn't work out their nationality, Japanese perhaps, but one of their number explained they were heading for the Stonehenge Campsite, about a mile away.  Clearly, the A303 had not quite been the road they had been expecting and a few of them looked a wee bit shaken.  We never did find out where they had cycled from.

It does raise another point about the A303 in this part of the West Country; it is a tourist area and people want to mover around the landscape on foot, on bikes and on horseback, as well as in and on motorised vehicles.  We hope that the government have sufficient foresight to construct a byway for this type of user.  One that runs alongside a dualled A303, but separated from it by barriers.  It should run from Amesbury (and ideally well east of Amesbury in time) all the way to Devon and Cornwall.  Such a facility would be welcomed by the many tourists, local, national and international, who flock to this area and put so much into the local economy.

It's interesting that such foresight was missing from the Wiltshire Council Local Transport Plan Cycling Strategy 2011-2026.

Another example of a missed opportunity by Wiltshire Council, where everyone matters, but where everything moves with slug-like velocity.

STOP PRESS: Abnormal Loads On The A303

Wiltshire Police are warning motorists to be aware of several abnormal loads that will be passing through the county this week, eastbound along a section of the A303.  Thank goodness they didn't try this on Monday with the chaos caused by a crash at Stonehenge and the crowds heading home after the Glastonbury Festival.

At approximately 11.00am on Wednesday 2nd July, three specialist load transporters carrying dump trucks will be escorted by Wiltshire Police from Whatley Quarry, Frome to the Parkhouse roundabout off the A303. The transporter will then continue its planned route (outside of the Wiltshire border) on the A303 and A34 before later joining the M4 where it will re-enter the county.  We think it is probably these little beauties making a return journey:

The same transporters carrying similar loads will then make an identical trip 24 hours later on Thursday 3rd July, also starting at approximately 11.00am.  You do have to question the common sense of whoever agreed to this happening on a Thursday, at a time when eastbound traffic is likely to be building up in the new A303 special - the advanced Friday rush hour.

The transporters and their loads will measure 5.75 metres (18ft 10ins) wide, 4.98m (16ft 4ins) high with an overall length of 23m (76ft) and gross weight of 117 tonnes.

Routes that are likely to be affected by the transportation are the eastbound stretches of the A361, A36, A350 and A303. The transporter will also be travelling on the A34 and M4 later in the afternoon.

Due to the size of the transporters, they will be slow moving and will have the potential to create congestion. Wherever possible, disruption will be kept to a minimum but hauliers and motorists are asked to please be patient if they come across this load. Anyone travelling over this period should allow sufficient additional time.

Regular updates and travel information in respect of the abnormal loads will be passed from our control room at Devizes when appropriate to help motorists plan their journey.

Police escorting resources are being provided by volunteer police officers on rest days, paid for by the haulier at no cost to the public.

Now how much easier would all this be if the A303 were dualled along its entire length?  Watch out for problems in Winterbourne Stoke if either of these convoys meet an HGV travelling westwards.